Switzerland, We Have A Problem

On Sunday November 29th, 2009 the citizens of Switzerland overwhelmingly passed a referendum banning the construction of new minarets in their country. With this move, the ban will be added to the Swiss Federal Constitution – a new and dubious level of status for an architectural element to reach.

Optimistically, let’s put aside questions of religious persecution and think about this as a design problem: what are the tensions within the built environment that made this ban possible? When the law is a flaw, what does design offer?

This is a tale of equality in confrontation with equanimity. One the one hand, the right to religious freedom should include reasonable material expression: every church with its cross, every mosque with its minaret [1]. On the other hand, the atmosphere and image of Switzerland’s picturesque Cantons are so finely crafted and manicured that formal deviation disturbs the calm.

To address this impasse between the rightful expression of the Muslim religion and the value of Switzerland’s overwhelmingly scenic environment we challenge you to design a solution that allows the best of both worlds. Can you design a minaret as event rather than object?

Your task is to design a deployable minaret that can attain full presence, visible from a distance, during each of the five daily calls to prayer.

You may use any technology you like, choose any site in Switzerland, and your minaret may reach any height so long as it’s at least twice as high as the building it sprouts from.

Format
Entries must be submitted as a single image that depicts both the deployed and hidden states.

Submission
Entries must be added to the Switzerland, We Have A Problem group pool on Flickr.

1. Get yourself a Flickr account.

2. Upload your image to your own Flickr account

3. Navigate to this page to add your image to the pool.

Deadline
All entries must be submitted no later than December 18 at 11:59PM Pacific Standard Time.

1] OK, so not every mosque has a minaret (actually there are only four in Switzerland), but every mosque should have the option to have one.

Bustler

Type Prijsvraag

Doelgroep designers

Meer informatie Bustler

Prijs -

Prijsuitreiking 30 december

Andere evenementen

16 november 2025 — 1 januari 2030

Modernisme in Beweging – Van Glaspaleis tot Parkstad

Vide in de centrale hal, SCHUNCK Glaspaleis, Heerlen

Deze expositie toont een selectie van modernistische gebouwen uit de regio en laat zien hoe architectuur uit de bloeitijd van de mijnindustrie vandaag een nieuwe betekenis krijgt.

18 september — 29 november 2026

IABR 2026 - Systems of Support

Piekfabriek, Piekstraat 2, 3071 EL Rotter

De IABR werpt het licht op de systemen die ons dagelijks leven mogelijk maken: van water, energie en materialen tot wonen en infrastructuur.

26 september 2026 — 31 januari 2027

A Chair and You - Stoelen zoals je ze nog nooit hebt gezien

Museumpark, Westzeedijk 341 3015 AA Rotterdam

Vanaf 26 september presenteert Kunsthal Rotterdam een groots overzicht gebaseerd op een van ’s werelds belangrijkste privécollecties van stoelen, samengebracht door verzamelaar Thierry Barbier-Mueller en geënsceneerd door Robert Wilson.

1 oktober — 19 december 2026

Gebouwen door Vrouwen in het Oostelijk Havengebied

Borneo Architectuur Centrum, R.J.H. Fortuynplein 4, Amsterdam

Borneo Architectuur Centrum en Gebouwen door Vrouwen hebben de handen ineengeslagen om álle door vrouwen ontworpen projecten (architectuur, stedenbouw, landschap en kunstwerken) in het Oostelijk Havengebied in kaart te brengen.